Top 10 All-Time New York Yankees (& Their Best Cards)

A Yankees baseball card is like none other. The New York Yankees franchise holds a place of immense significance in the world of baseball, both in the United States and globally. By extension, so do their cards.

Established in 1901, the Yankees are one of the most storied and successful franchises in Major League Baseball history. Their rich tradition is characterized by an unparalleled record of success. They’ve won an astonishing 27 World Series championships, more than any other team in the history of the sport. This unparalleled success is a testament to the Yankees’ commitment to excellence, their ability to attract and develop top talent, and their enduring legacy as a symbol of baseball greatness.

The Yankees’ significance extends beyond their on-field achievements. They’ve played a pivotal role in shaping the culture and commercialization of baseball, with their distinctive pinstripe uniforms, the iconic Yankee Stadium, and a passionate and widespread fan base. You can expect to see Yankees caps not only in the Bronx, but throughout every continent on Earth.

The team’s brand is synonymous with excellence, tradition, and a commitment to winning. To be one of the top Yankees of all-time is to be one of the greatest to play the game. Here are the top 10 Yankees and a must-have Yankees baseball card for each:

10. Alex Rodriguez

Alex Rodriguez, commonly known as A-Rod, had an eventful and productive career as a New York Yankee from 2004 to 2016. During his time in pinstripes, he achieved both individual success and contributed significantly to the team’s performance. A-Rod earned seven All-Star selections during his Yankees years and captured two American League MVP awards in 2005 and 2007. He consistently hit for both power and average, making him a force at the plate.

The Texas Rangers traded A-Rod to the New York Yankees in 2004, completing one of the most significant and controversial deals in baseball history. He also signed some of the largest contracts in the sport. In 2001, he agreed to a 10-year, $252 million deal with the Rangers, setting a record at the time. In 2007, he broke his own record by signing a 10-year, $275 million contract with the Yankees.

A-Rod’s career produced impressive statistics, including 696 home runs – 351 of them with the Yankees. He regularly led the league in categories like home runs, slugging percentage, and total bases. His versatility, including a transition from shortstop to third base, demonstrated his commitment to the team’s success.

In 2013, Major League Baseball suspended Rodriguez for the entire 2014 season for his involvement in the Biogenesis scandal, which centered on performance-enhancing drugs. The suspension ranked among the longest in baseball history and continues to impact his Hall of Fame candidacy.

After retiring following the 2016 season, A-Rod built a successful second career as a baseball broadcaster and analyst.

Best Yankees baseball card: 2021 Topps Sterling Swings #SWAR-AR Alex Rodriguez

Since Alex Rodriguez played for the Mariners and Rangers before he joined the Yankees, you can strike many of his coveted cards off the list because they pre-date his days in New York. His best Yankees baseball cards are those containing on-card autographs and game-used materials, and this one has both. The card costs $150-$300 ungraded.

9. Bill Dickey

Bill Dickey, a Hall of Fame catcher, played an integral role for the New York Yankees from 1928 to 1946, a period marked by team dominance. Dickey powered the Yankees’ success with consistent excellence. He earned 11 All-Star selections during his career and helped lead the team to four consecutive World Series championships from 1936 to 1939.

Dickey excelled as a defensive catcher, showing off a strong arm, quick release, and sharp ability to handle pitchers. He managed the Yankees’ pitching staff during their many World Series runs and anchored the defense with his durability, catching more than 100 games in 13 different seasons—an impressive feat given the position’s physical demands. At the plate, Dickey hit .313 and launched over 200 home runs, providing reliable offense as well.

He also mentored a young Yogi Berra, playing a crucial role in shaping one of baseball’s future greats. Dickey’s steady presence gave the Yankees stability during their era of dominance, and his influence helped ensure the team’s long-term success.

During his time with the Yankees, Dickey captured seven World Series championships, becoming one of the most decorated catchers in baseball history. His .313 career batting average underscored his offensive prowess. As one of the most respected catchers of his era, Dickey remained a vital component of the Yankees’ dynasty throughout the late 1930s. The Hall of Fame honored him with induction in 1954.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1934-1936 National Chicle Diamond Stars Bill Dickey #11

With “New York” emblazoned on his chest, this baseball card came from the prime of Bill Dickey’s career. The National Chicle set, while not as widely known, is a beautiful, full-color set with tons of 1930s stars. Excellent to mint condition examples of Dickey’s card cost between $500-$1,500.

8. Mariano Rivera

Mariano Rivera ranks as the greatest closer in baseball history. He spent his entire 19-year career with the New York Yankees, from 1995 to 2013. Rivera dominated hitters with his presence on the mound and anchored the Yankees’ success with his unparalleled consistency. He earned 13 All-Star selections during his Yankees years and helped the team win five World Series championships, playing a critical role in their postseason victories. In 1999, he captured World Series MVP honors, a rare achievement for a relief pitcher that underscored his immense impact on the game.

His remarkable regular season career included a record 652 saves, 952 games finished – both MLB bests – and the best ERA+ of all-time. He finished the season with 40+ saves seven times, and 50+ saves twice.

Rivera’s signature pitch, the cut fastball, was nearly impossible to hit. The defining feature of a cut fastball is its horizontal movement. As it approaches the plate, it will break or “cut” slightly in the direction of the pitcher’s throwing arm. For a right-handed pitcher, this means the ball will move from right to left as it reaches the batter. Left-handed pitchers will see the opposite movement.

Fans also knew Rivera as “The Sandman,” a nickname inspired by his entrance music, “Enter Sandman” by Metallica. Hearing the song blast over the loudspeakers struck fear into opposing batters and electrified Yankees fans. The song became an iconic part of Yankees lore, adding to the drama of Rivera’s appearances. In 2019, Rivera made history by earning induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame with 100% of the vote – the first player ever to achieve that feat.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1996 Leaf Signature Mariano Rivera

It’s tough to choose between Mariano Rivera’s rookie card from the 1992 Bowman set, and this one, his first certified autograph. The 1996 Leaf Signature wins because it’s a nicely composed card and certified autographs were fairly rare at the time. It’s available in gold, silver and bronze editions. It’s one of the finer modern Yankees baseball cards, and you can find them for $150-$300.

7. Whitey Ford

Edward Charles “Whitey” Ford, a left-handed pitcher, spent his entire illustrious 18-year career with the New York Yankees from 1950 to 1967. He was a cornerstone of the Yankees’ success during his tenure. His impressive statistics and accolades highlight his incredible impact. Ford was a six-time World Series champion and a 10-time All-Star. This was all a testament to his consistency and performance on the mound.

Ford was known for his precise control and ability to handle high-pressure situations. His nickname, “The Chairman of the Board,” reflected his calm and composed demeanor on the mound. He had a remarkable postseason career, amassing 10 World Series victories, which earned him the moniker “The Money Player.” His contributions to the Yankees during their championship runs solidified his legacy as one of the most dependable and celebrated pitchers in the history of the game.

Ford’s career win-loss record of 236-106, combined with an ERA of 2.75, showcases his remarkable pitching abilities. He won two ERA titles in his career, as well as a Cy Young award in 1961. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1974.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1962 Topps #315 “Whitey Ford Tosses a Curve”

Whitey Ford’s 1962 Topps baseball card is cool for two reasons. First, it is a rare in-game photo on a 1960s card, used to great effect here. Secondly, the photo was taken during Ford’s Cy Young season in 1961, so it’s nice to imagine that the curveball depicted on the card contributed to that wonderful season. Ford’s card is under $100 in PSA 8 condition. It’s very attainable for the collector with a taste for vintage cards.

6. Derek Jeter

Derek Jeter, affectionately known as “The Captain,” built a storied 20-year career with the New York Yankees from 1995 to 2014. Jeter made an immense impact on both the team and the game of baseball. A 14-time All-Star, five-time Gold Glove winner, and five-time Silver Slugger award recipient, he excelled as a well-rounded player both offensively and defensively. He played a pivotal role in the Yankees’ championship runs in the late 1990s and 2000s, helping the team capture five World Series titles.

Jeter delivered legendary clutch performances in the postseason and earned World Series MVP honors in 2000. He set numerous postseason records, including most hits, runs, and doubles, cementing his reputation as a true October legend. With 3,465 hits, Jeter surpassed all others to become the Yankees’ all-time hits leader, further solidifying his place among the greatest players in franchise history.

Off the field, Jeter earned widespread respect for his leadership and professionalism. He founded the Turn 2 Foundation, encouraging young people to avoid drugs and alcohol and embrace healthy lifestyles. In 2020, the Baseball Hall of Fame honored Jeter with induction.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1993 SP Derek Jeter #279 (RC)

Like many modern players, Derek Jeter has a lot of rookie cards. The one recognized as his best baseball card is the 1993 SP Derek Jeter #279. It’s one of the most iconic rookie cards ever and has the classic early 90s aesthetic, complete with chrome. It’s also one of the classic Yankees baseball cards. In many ways, the card feels like a throwback to the 1940s, when photos appeared over plain backgrounds. Finding one in gem mint condition is nearly impossible, and one recently sold for over $200,000. According to PSA, lesser-condition versions range widely in price, from several hundred to several thousand dollars. For those with shallower pockets, Jeter’s other famous rookie – the 1993 Topps Derek Jeter RC #98—typically sells for around $350.

5. Yogi Berra

Yogi Berra was a beloved figure and a legendary catcher during his 18-year career with the New York Yankees. From 1946 to 1963, Berra led the team through an era of exceptional success and numerous championships. An 18-time All-Star and a 10-time World Series champion, Berra became synonymous with winning. His 10 World Series titles remain the most by any player in history, highlighting his extraordinary contribution to the Yankees’ dynasty. He later added three more titles as a manager and coach with other organizations.

Berra showcased unmatched skills as a catcher and stood out as an outstanding hitter, posting a career batting average of .285 and hitting 358 home runs. He earned three American League MVP awards, cementing his place among the greatest Yankees and the most iconic players in baseball history.

Fans and media also adored Berra for his witty and oft-quoted “Yogi-isms.” Phrases like “It’s déjà vu all over again” crossed over into pop culture and became known far beyond the baseball world.

Yogi Berra’s remarkable career and his lasting contributions to baseball, both as a player and a coach, left an indelible mark on the game and its fans. The Baseball Hall of Fame honored him with induction in 1972.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1950 Bowman #46 Yogi Berra

Berra’s Yankees baseball cards are surprisingly affordable, at least compared to his contemporaries. In many ways, including cards, he doesn’t get the respect he deserves. This Berra card is beautiful. For the time, it was rare to see a catcher in a pose with full gear, and the unusual landscape presentation is a bold choice. Even the coloring on this nearly 75 year old card is great. A PSA 6 can be purchased for approximately $500-$1,000. In ungraded but poor condition, it’s yours for $150-$300.

4. Joe DiMaggio

Joe DiMaggio, known as “The Yankee Clipper,” enjoyed a legendary career with the New York Yankees from 1936 to 1951. His time with the team was marked by remarkable achievements, cementing his legacy as one of the greatest players in baseball history. DiMaggio made a profound impact, earning 13 All-Star selections and nine World Series championships throughout his career.

A three-time American League MVP and two-time batting champion, DiMaggio’s consistent excellence at the plate remained unmatched. He became famous for his remarkable 56-game hitting streak in 1941, a record that still stands today. DiMaggio’s combination of power and grace, both in the outfield and at the plate, set him apart. His 361 career home runs and .325 batting average underscore his incredible talent.

Remarkably, DiMaggio missed three prime years of his career (ages 28-30) serving in the U.S. Army Air Forces during World War II. He also gained widespread attention for his high-profile marriage to iconic actress Marilyn Monroe in 1954. Their tumultuous relationship continues to captivate popular culture, with artifacts like pieces of their preserved wedding cake occasionally appearing at auction.

DiMaggio’s career stands as a testament to leadership, skill, and championship success. The Baseball Hall of Fame inducted him in 1955.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1941 Play Ball #76 Joe DiMaggio

The 1940 and 1941 Playball sets used the same photo (one in color and one B&W). However, the 1941 card wins the day because this was also the year DiMaggio hit in 56 consecutive games. It’s a legendary achievement that has never been broken. Owing to their age, most of DiMaggio’s cards are in the “expensive, but not record-breaking” category when it comes to cost. This card is no exception. For a PSA 4-6, expect to pay around $5,000-$10,000.

3. Lou Gehrig

Lou Gehrig, often called the “Iron Horse,” spent his entire career with the New York Yankees from 1923 to 1939. His contributions to both the team and the sport were immeasurable. A seven-time All-Star and six-time World Series champion, Gehrig helped lead the Yankees to dominance during the 1920s and 1930s. His consistency and remarkable abilities made him a beloved figure in baseball.

Gehrig’s most famous achievement came with his streak of playing in 2,130 consecutive games, a record that lasted for 56 years. A two-time American League MVP and three-time batting champion, he finished his career with a .340 batting average, 493 home runs, and 1,995 RBIs.

In contrast to his flamboyant teammate Babe Ruth, Gehrig remained known for his quiet, humble, and unassuming demeanor on and off the field. He often signed baseballs on the side panel so Ruth could sign the sweet spot. As team captain, Gehrig displayed strong leadership qualities and earned the respect of both his teammates and opponents.

Gehrig’s illness and early retirement in 1939 marked a heartbreaking chapter in sports history. Diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), a progressive and fatal neurological disease, Gehrig faced his fate with remarkable courage. During his farewell speech at Yankee Stadium on July 4, 1939, he famously declared, “I consider myself the luckiest man on the face of the earth,” solidifying the moment as one of the most poignant in baseball history.

Gehrig’s courage in the face of ALS, his humility, and his enduring love for the game left an indelible mark. Through the 1942 film The Pride of the Yankees, starring Gary Cooper, Gehrig became an icon, beloved in New York and far beyond. The Baseball Hall of Fame inducted him in 1939 by special election.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1934 Goudey #37 Lou Gehrig

Gehrig’s 1925 Exhibits card is one of the most expensive in history. That makes the 1934 Lou Gehrig a bargain by comparison. There are actually two Gehrig cards on this set. It’s unique because he’s provided a “Lou Gehrig says” on each card, including his own. This card has sold for six-figures in the past. However, you can find a PSA 2-4 for a slightly more reasonable $3,000-$10,000.

2. Mickey Mantle

Mickey Mantle played his entire 18-year career in pinstripes from 1951 to 1968. Mantle’s combination of power and speed made him one of the most exciting players to watch. He was Rookie of the Year, a 20-time All-Star, a three-time American League MVP, and a seven-time World Series champion.

Mantle’s ability to hit tape-measure home runs left a lasting legacy in the world of baseball. He hit one of the longest home runs in baseball history, estimated at 643 feet, at Griffith Stadium in Washington, D.C., in 1953. In total, he accumulated 536 career home runs and maintained a lifetime .298 batting average. His switch-hitting prowess was a rare and valuable asset, allowing him to be a formidable presence from both sides of the plate. Expect to pay around $20,000-$50,000 for a PSA 4-6, with ungraded versions available for a lower price.

Despite his remarkable success, Mantle’s career was marked by injuries. He suffered from various ailments, including knee problems, which many believe prevented him from reaching his full potential. Nonetheless, his dynamic style of play and incredible achievements secured his status as one of the greatest Yankees and one of the most celebrated players in baseball history. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1974.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle (RC)

An obvious choice for this entry is the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle, which is both one of the most iconic and the most expensive cards of all time. But the choice here is the 1951 Bowman #253, which is Mantle’s true rookie card. The art on the card is beautiful and, while the design is spartan, it works.

1. Babe Ruth

Babe Ruth, often known as the “Sultan of Swat” or “The Bambino,” is arguably the greatest baseball player of all time. His time with the New York Yankees from 1920 to 1934 became the stuff of legends. As a Yankee, Ruth won four World Series titles, claimed 10 home run championships, and earned the AL MVP award in 1923. His impact on the game was immeasurable – he popularized the home run and fundamentally changed how baseball was played, ushering the sport out of the Deadball Era and making power hitting both popular and profitable.

Ruth’s career record of 714 home runs remained unbroken for decades, and he finished with a career batting average of .342. His iconic left-handed swing and unprecedented ability to drive the ball out of the park made him one of the most feared and beloved figures in sports.

Ruth’s feats often bordered on the mythical. In the 1932 World Series, his first with the Yankees, he is said to have famously “called his shot” by pointing to the outfield fence before hitting a home run. The exact details of this story remain a subject of debate, only amplifying Ruth’s mystique and legendary status in the sport.

Beyond his astonishing statistics, Ruth’s larger-than-life personality and charm helped define the sport and the New York Yankees’ legacy. In 1936, he was one of five members of the inaugural class of the Baseball Hall of Fame.

Best Yankees baseball card: 1932 R328 U.S. Caramel #32 Babe Ruth

We’ve chronicled some of the best Babe Ruth cards in a previous article. Our selection here is considered the sixth entry on that list. The 1932 U.S. Caramel Yankees baseball card shows a portrait of Ruth with his iconic Yankees cap casually placed on top of his head. According to PSA, these cards were regional issues, and an offer on the back allows collectors to exchange them for a coupon. Both factors increase the rarity of the set. As with many vintage cards, PSA has never catalogued a gem mint 10. Although copies of PSA 9s have sold for six-figures, you can expect to pay $30,000 for a mid-grade example.